The use of the ALL options expected to provide all combinations of search logic for the terms presented but does not provide logic for cross field entries. Example criteria:
"word1 word2" AND word4
OR
word3 AND word4
This criteria is expected to provide 8 logic combinations for 'To or from' and 'Subject or content'. The logic expected, where 'name:' is for the To or from fields and 'text:' is for the Subject or content fields, is:
name: "word1 word2" AND name: word4
name: word3 AND name: word4
name: "word1 word2" AND text: word4
name: word3 AND text: word4
text: "word1 word2" AND name: word4
text: word3 AND name: word4
text: "word1 word2" AND text: word4
text: word3 AND text: word4
The logic actually presented by the ALL option is
name: "word1 word2" AND name: word4
name: word3 AND name: word4
text: "word1 word2" AND text: word4
text: word3 AND text: word4
Workaround:
To obtain all 8 logic combinations, 3 searches will need to be run. The criteria for these searches would be:
Search 1:
To or from > Any of > "word1 word2"
word3
Subject or content > Any of > word4

The above criteria equates to the following logic:
name "word1 word2" AND text word4
OR
name word3 AND text word4
Search 2:
To or from > Any of > word4
Subject or content > Any of > "word1 word2"
word3

The above criteria equates to the following logic:
name word4 AND text "word1 word2"
OR
name word4 AND text word3
Search 3:
ALL > Any of > "word1 word2" +word4
word3 +word4

The above criteria equates to the following logic:
text "word1 word2" AND text word4
OR
name "word1 word2" AND name word4
OR
text word3 AND text word4
OR
name word3 AND name word4
This issue has been addressed in EV 14.3.